A picture of the hefty bill by Antico Caffè di Marte restaurant, near Castel Sant’Angelo, made the rounds on social media after it was posted on Facebook earlier in September.
In addition to the €349.50 total for food, the tourists were charged an extra €80 for the tip.
A number of other diners have also come forward to claim that they, too, have been ripped off by the restaurant.
Minh Ngoc Bui, who is Vietnamese but lives in Germany, is one of several people who left accounts on Tripadvisor of their alleged experiences at the establishment.
Along with three other friends, Minh was having lunch at Antico Caffè on August 27 when the waiter suggested the “seafood — mixed fish” dish from the menu, with a price of €6.5 per 100 grams, she told CNN.
Tourist complaints over rip-off Rome restaurant mount after viral $500 bill
Minh Ngoc Bui
“We agreed because It would be not a big deal to pay €6.5 extra to try a recommendation dish,” Minh said. “But they brought us only one plate of mixed fish around 2 kg.”
“We were kind of surprised when we saw this dish because we didn’t expect ‘100 grams fish’ would be this big. But it was our last day in Italy so we told ourselves it was OK. It’s around 2 kg of fish so I agreed to pay around €130-150 for this dish of fish. We don’t want to have more drama in Italy.”
But when one of her friends asked for the bill, he was asked to pay for 4.8 kg of mixed fish at a cost of €315, Minh said.
Adding €40 of service fee and €40 for the tip, the whole bill was a staggering €476.40.
Tourist complaints over rip-off Rome restaurant mount after viral $500 bill
Minh Ngoc Bui
“He complained that this could not be this much and he doesn’t agree to pay this much for the service and tip, they did not announce clearly about this rule on the menu. But they told him that the service and tip were the rules and we really ate that much,” the woman said. “He tried to complain but they forced him to pay. So he paid by himself.”
When Minh later found out about the bill, she suggested to her friend that they return to the restaurant to complain.
“When we returned, I asked the man who served us to put 4.8 kg of mixed seafood on that plate. Because I firmly believe that it is impossible and they cannot do it. And just like I thought, they couldn’t do it and refused to do it with the excuse that they didn’t have time,” she said.
They tried to report the restaurant to police, but authorities told them they should have called before the payment, Minh said.
CNN has contacted the Antico Caffè di Marte restaurant for comment.
“Everything is written in detail, just look at the prices: €16 maximum for a spaghetti with seafood,” Giacomo Jin, the owner, said, according to the paper. “To pay that figure, the [Japanese] girls ordered not only spaghetti, but also fish. On the other hand, our fish is fresh: the client picks it at the counter, we weigh it and we cook it.”
As far as the tip was concerned, Jin said it was voluntary and the client could choose between 10 and 20% of the total amount.